Peer review

Structural peer review

For developers, builders, certifiers and other engineers. An independent, senior check of a structural design: is it safe, does it comply, and could it be simpler or cheaper to build?

When a peer review helps

Typical reasons clients ask for one:

  • A client, financier or certifier requires an independent check
  • A complex or unusual structure needs a second opinion
  • The design seems heavy, and you suspect it's over-designed
  • A builder wants to propose an alternative scheme
  • A dispute or defect needs an independent view
  • Checking a design before it goes to tender
  • Specialist analysis (vibration, seismic, complex geometry) needs checking
  • Another engineer wants an independent check of their own work

What you get

Proportionate to the risk: from a focused check of one element to a full independent review.

Design review

A review of the drawings, calculations and design basis against the relevant Australian Standards and the NCC.

Independent checks

Our own calculations or analysis for the critical elements, not just a read-through.

Review report

Clear findings, sorted into must-fix issues, recommendations and opportunities to save cost.

Comments register

A register of comments and responses, closed out with the design engineer.

Value engineering

Where it's worth it, alternative schemes that are simpler or cheaper to build.

Close-out letter

A letter confirming the review is complete and the comments have been resolved.

How it works

  1. 01

    Agree the scope

    What's being reviewed, to what depth, and who the report is for.

  2. 02

    Review and check

    We review the design and run independent checks on the critical elements.

  3. 03

    Report

    Findings issued in a report and comments register, discussed with the design engineer where that helps.

  4. 04

    Close out

    Responses reviewed and closed out, then a close-out letter issued.

Email drawings, photos or sketches to info@three16.com.au, or call 0405 516 358 to talk it through first.

Review experience

Shell House, Wynyard Place, Sydney

Richard reviewed the concept scheme (post-tensioned concrete inside a heritage facade) and recommended a composite steel and concrete alternative better suited to the constrained site. Delivering it led to TTW winning all three Wynyard Place buildings.

Delivered with a previous employer.

Shell House heritage facade, Wynyard Place Sydney

Sydney Metro Northwest

Reworking the station steelwork from a multi-truss scheme to a cantilever system cut the steel package cost by about 20%.

Delivered with a previous employer.

Bella Vista station canopy, Sydney Metro Northwest

More on Richard's background in the capability statement and his full CV.

Common questions

Will you just tell us what's wrong?

No. A good review also says what's right, and where the design could be simpler or cheaper. Must-fix issues are clearly separated from preferences.

Do you work with the original engineer?

Yes, ideally. Most issues resolve quickly in a conversation. We stay independent, but the review is meant to improve the design, not score points.

How long does a review take?

It depends on the size and depth of review. We'll give you a timeframe with the fee, once we've seen the documents.

Where do you work?

We're based on the Central Coast of NSW and work with clients across Australia. Locally we're on site quickly; further afield we work from drawings, photos and site visits as the job needs.

Need a design reviewed?

Send the drawings and calculations, and tell us why you need the review, and we'll come back with a scope, fee and timeframe.

Send them to info@three16.com.au.